Welcome to Il Compare Restaurant
We offer a charming, intimate, family restaurant and our courteous staff provides pleasant and prompt service, making everyone feel like family! Every item on our Restaurant menu is made with only the freshest ingredients with generous portions. Every item on our menu is available for takeout.

Every Wednesday night Il Compare Restaurant features live entertainment for your dining pleasure. We have a full bar as well as an extensive Wine List for your distinctive palate.

Our Restaurant facilities are available for:

Private Parties
Corporate Dinners
Anniversaries
Bridal Showers
Baby Showers
Birthday Celebrations
Special Events

Reservations are not required, but to ensure seating at your preferred time we do suggest you make reservations. For reservations and additional information, give us a call - 845.832.3411.

Il Compare Family Restaurant
"If you are looking for an Italian restaurant that is a cut above, this is the place for you!" - R. Roll, Philadelphia Pa.


Fine Italian Restaurant
"Delicious food in casual, comfortable yet classy restaurant surroundings. Overall, a great experience. Best Escargot Appetizer ever. Hubby had 'Penne Bolognese' which rivaled any Italian Nona’s dish. Reasonably priced, comprehensive wine list. The red snapper special was fresh and perfectly prepared with fresh garlic and tomatoes... Yummy tiramisu for dessert! Go!" – Restaurant DB Review
Italian American Cuisine
"I've had mussels, steak, eggplant Parmigiana, martinis, brushetti, pasta, etc...you can not go wrong with anything on that menu! Karen, the owner, is an absolute doll and she makes you feel like you are the most important customer/friend in the place. The restaurant staff is as well very friendly. Going there again this weekend!" - Carolyn, N.Y.
Dining Room
"Fantastic food all the way around. A favorite restaurant for us. Everything tastes fresh & delicious. I recommend it highly!!" – Yahoo Reviews